Sunday, 15 Nov, 2026
CLOSE

Luscious Stovetop Mac and Cheese

>

Creamy mac and cheese on a plate.

It’s Party Mac and Cheese.



Lindsay Ostrom headshot.

THIS MAC AND CHEESE IS SO GOOD.Thick, creamy, and I might even say Panera-style in its creamy, cheesy, velvety glory.This summer, my daughter and my husband biked 50+ miles to raise money for frogs (I know, can’t make this up, but stick with me). We had a little welcome home party at the end of the bike ride, and I made this mac and cheese for 25 people at that party. Multiple friends came up and asked me for the recipe.Since then, I’ve made this several more times, always when we have friends for dinner or I’m feeding a big group of people.So in my mind, this is a party mac and cheese. You can serve it to a lot of people, and mostly everyone will love it.

Luscious Stovetop Mac and Cheese

(Pictured here with the BBQ meatballs that I made for our friends last night! So yum.)When I do this for a group of people, I’ll do a couple things ahead of time:Cook the noodles.Make the bechamel.Shred the cheese.Then when it’s time to assemble, I reheat the bechamel, add the cheese, and stir the noodles in. A bit of warm water at the end helps it stay loose and creamy!My favorite cheese lately has been the cheddar and Gruyere blend blocks that you can buy at ALDI or Trader Joe’s, but I also love some straight cheddar or even a few slices of American for a milder, creamier finish.It’s just uncluttered, creamy, comforting homemade mac and cheese. Hope you love it!

Lindsay signature.

How To Make This Mac And Cheese (Step-By-Step)

1

Grab Your Ingredients.

Pasta, cheese, butter, milk – all the essentials!

Ingredients for mac and cheese.

2

Cook Noodles.

Cook your noodles and set aside (I love to use classic elbow macaroni!).

Cooked noodles being drained.

3

Start a Roux.

Melt butter, add flour, and whisk until nice and bubbly!

Butter and flour in a skillet.

4

dd Milk and Cream.Go slowly and whisk after each little bit. Stir stir stir until it’s nice and smooth and thickened.

Adding milk to roux.

5

Melt in the Cheese.

Chef’s choice, but I like Gruyere and mild cheddar!

Adding shredded cheese to sauce.

7

dd Noodles.Add your noodles and bring it all together!

Noodles added to cheese sauce.

8

Serve!

That’s it! Cheesy, comforting, and so good.

Mac and cheese in a skillet.

Print

Creamy mac and cheese on a plate.

Creamy Stovetop Mac and Cheese

5 Stars 4 Stars 3 Stars 2 Stars 1 Star

5 from 4 reviews

Author: Lindsay Ostrom

Luscious Stovetop Mac and Cheese

Total Time:30 minutes

Luscious Stovetop Mac and Cheese

Yield:810 servings 1x Print Pin const share_pin_buttons = document.getElementsByClassName( 'share-pin button' ); if ( share_pin_buttons ) { for ( let share_key = 0; share_key { e.stopPropagation(); window.open(e.target.dataset.href,'targetWindow','toolbar=no,location=no,status=no,menubar=no,scrollbars=yes,resizable=yes,width=500,height=500'); return false;>

Description

Thick and creamy mac and cheese! People always ask me for this recipe. We call it party mac and cheese because it’s perfect for a crowd!

Ingredients

UnitsUSM1lbelbow macaroni4 tablespoonssalted butter3 tablespoonsall-purpose flour1/2 teaspoononion powder (optional)1/2 teaspoonkosher salt 2 1/2cups2% milk1/2cupheavy cream4cupsfreshly shredded cheese (15 ounces, or two blocks – I use mild cheddar and Gruyere)1/2cup to 3/4 cup warm water at the endCook Mode Prevent your screen from going dark

Instructions

Grate Your Cheese: This recipe works best if you grate your own cheese! Cook Noodles: Cook the elbow macaroni according to package directions, with a generous pinch of salt added to the water. Drain, set aside, and drizzle with a bit of oil to prevent noodles from sticking.Butter and Flour: In a large skillet or Dutch oven, melt the butter over medium low heat. Add flour; whisk to incorporate. Let it bubble for 2-3 minutes to cook out any floury taste. Add onion powder and salt.Add Milk: Slowly add the milk, 1/2 cup at a time. It’ll start out clumpy, but as you whisk and add more liquid, it will turn into a smooth and thickened sauce.Add Cream: Add heavy cream; simmer and whisk until the sauce is smooth and lightly thickened. Turn the heat off. (You want it to be warm enough to melt the cheese, but not boiling hot.)Add Cheese: Add the grated cheese to the warm sauce. Stir to melt completely. (If it’s not melting smoothly, put it back on low heat).Finish: Add your noodles. Stir to coat. It’ll be cheesy and delicious. This is where you’ll add warm water, a little bit at a time, to reach your desired final consistency. Serve immediately!

Notes

This will thicken up as it rests, so it is best to serve almost immediately.

If you want to prep it ahead (which I do quite a bit, being that it’s party mac and cheese) – I cook the noodles ahead, grate the cheese ahead, and even make the bechamel sauce with the flour, butter, and milk. Then, right before serving, I re-warm the sauce (adding water and whisking to bring make it smooth again), gently melt the cheese in, and toss the noodles in the sauce.



Luscious Stovetop Mac and Cheese

Prep Time:10 minutes

Luscious Stovetop Mac and Cheese

Cook Time:20 minutes

Luscious Stovetop Mac and Cheese

Category:Dinner

Luscious Stovetop Mac and Cheese

Method:Stovetop

Luscious Stovetop Mac and Cheese

Cuisine:AmericanKeywords: stovetop mac and cheese, easy mac and cheese, panera mac and cheese, mac and cheese recipe

Did you make this recipe?

I love hearing from you! Leave a comment or rating below!

More Easy Dreamy Pasta RecipeS



Pumpkin Rigatoni pasta dish with Walnut Crispies in a bowl with fork.

Pumpkin Rigatoni


Mushroom fettuccine on plate with fork.

Mushroom Fettuccine


Roasted red pepper pasta in a skillet.

Red Pepper Pasta

The post Creamy Stovetop Mac and Cheese appeared first on Pinch of Yum.